Differential Privacy (DP) has become a gold standard in privacy-preserving data analysis. While it provides one of the most rigorous notions of privacy, there are many settings where its applicability is limited.Our main contribution is in augmenting differential privacy with {\em Flexible Accuracy}, which allows small distortions in the input (e.g., droppingoutliers) before measuring accuracy of the output, allowing one to extend DPmechanisms to high-sensitivity functions. We present mechanisms that can help in achieving this notion for functions that had no meaningful differentially private mechanisms previously. In particular, we illustrate an application to differentially private histograms, which in turn yields mechanisms for revealing the support of a dataset or the extremal values in the data. Analyses of our constructions exploit newversatile composition theorems that facilitate modular design. All the above extensions use our new definitional framework, which is in terms of ``lossy Wasserstein distance'' -- a 2-parameter error measure for distributions. This may be of independent interest.